w1n5t0n/memlnaut-nisps
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions
memlnaut-nisps/docs/specs/recon/playground-2026.md

14 KiB
Raw Blame History

kind date immutable
finding 2026-04-12 true

Playground Redesign — 2026 (Design Intent)

Purpose of this doc. Captures design intent of an unfinished playground UI redesign that lived as uncommitted changes in a MEMLNaut-NISPS_rewound working copy. The implementation will not be merged into the current vanilla playground — the playground is being rewritten in SolidJS — but the design shouldn't be lost. Read this as a reference for the SolidJS rewrite, not as a description of current code.

Source snapshot. archive/playground-redesign-2026-snapshot branch in this repo. Single commit 287e3a1 on top of ddb6b77. Three files: playground/a-immersive.html, playground/css/a-immersive.css, playground/js/a-app.js. ~1200 lines net of changes.

Status. Reference-only, immutable. Do not merge into the vanilla playground — those files have moved on independently in main and a textual merge would be meaningless.

Context

The pre-redesign playground UI was organised around a collapsible bottom sheet containing a sticky floating bar (mode toggles, train/randomize buttons, follow toggle, expand chevron). The sheet would expand upward to show synth/visual controls. RL thumbs-up/down floating buttons sat just above the collapsed sheet at bottom: 92px.

The redesign moves to a right-side macOS-style dock + drawer system and makes the top heatmap strip directly interactive. It also adds undo for RL actions and a per-parameter override system that unifies how visual-mode and synth-mode parameters can be constrained.

There are five themes, summarised here in decreasing order of architectural weight.

Theme 1 — Right-side dock + drawer system

What changed

Replaces the bottom-sheet pattern with a vertical dock pinned to the right edge of the viewport, plus a stack of named drawers that open to the left of the dock when their dock icon is activated.

  • Removed: <div class="bottom-sheet collapsed">, <div class="floating-bar">, the sheet expand/collapse chevron, sheet-internal sticky mode bar, sheet status line.
  • Removed JS: wireBottomSheet(), $bottomSheet, $sheetContent, $floatingBar, $chevronBtn, sheetExpanded state.
  • Added: <div class="dock" id="dock"> with five icon buttons:
    • data-drawer="training" — Training (Add Example, Train, Clear Ex, Clear All, Randomize, plus preset chips: Calm/Chaos, Rainbow, Vortex, Spiral, Embers; loss-canvas section)
    • data-drawer="mode" — Input/Output mode toggles (was the floating-bar pill toggles: Joystick/Hands and Visual/Synth)
    • data-drawer="synth" — Synth controls
    • data-drawer="params" — Engine parameters (see Theme 4)
    • data-drawer="help" — Help
  • Added: <div class="drawer-stack" id="drawer-stack"> containing one <div class="drawer hidden" data-drawer="…"> per icon, each with a drawer-header (title + close ×) and drawer-body.
  • Added JS: wireDock() to hook up icon clicks and drawer close buttons.

Inferred intent

  • Reclaim canvas real estate. The bottom-sheet ate vertical space whenever expanded; a side dock keeps controls flush to one edge and only one drawer opens at a time.
  • Surface mode controls (Visual/Synth, Joystick/Hands) without forcing the user to expand the sheet. Each function lives behind one click on a labeled icon.
  • macOS-dock visual idiom is a familiar metaphor — users intuit "click icon → panel appears."
  • The action-row inside Training drawer (Add Example / Train / Clear Ex / Clear All / Randomize) is grouped by purpose rather than by toolbar real estate constraints, so destructive/dim variants (.action-btn.dim) read as secondary.

Key UX flow

  1. Canvas is fullscreen by default, no chrome over it except top heatmap, RL buttons, joystick, and the right dock.
  2. User clicks dock icon → corresponding drawer slides in from the right (between dock and canvas), other drawers close.
  3. User clicks ✕ on drawer header or the same dock icon again → drawer closes, canvas is unobstructed.
  4. Mutually exclusive drawers (only one open at a time) keeps the visual hierarchy simple.

Implementation notes for SolidJS rewrite

  • This is the largest theme and pulls HTML, CSS, and JS together. In SolidJS it should naturally become a <Dock> component listing icon → drawer pairs, plus a single <DrawerStack> rendering whichever is active from a signal.
  • CSS custom properties --dock-width: 48px and --dock-gap: 8px are introduced; layout (joystick, hand-pip, dev-panel) is offset by these.
  • Old positioning constants — joystick & hand-pip at bottom: 136px, RL buttons at bottom: 92px — were tied to the collapsed bottom sheet's 88px height. With no sheet, they shift down (joystick/hand-pip to 100px, RL buttons to 36px). The rewrite should drive these from layout, not hardcode.
  • dev-panel shifts right edge from right: 16px to right: calc(var(--dock-width) + 24px) to clear the dock.

Theme 2 — Interactive heatmap strip

What changed

The top heatmap strip — previously read-only visualization of model outputs — becomes the primary parameter input surface.

Two interactions per cell

  1. Drag (pointermove with motion threshold > 3px) horizontally across a cell → directly sets that parameter's value to the normalized x-position within the cell.
  2. Click (pointerup with no motion) → toggles a per-parameter popup with override controls (min, max, curve, freeze).

Tooltip

Existing tooltip extended:

  • During hover (no drag): shows {name}: {value} with a ▾ indicator hinting the bar is clickable.
  • During drag: stays visible and updates live as user scrubs.
  • New CSS: .heatmap-cell.dragging with cursor: ew-resize, .heatmap-cell-bar { pointer-events: none } so child bar doesn't intercept parent pointer events.

Popup contents

Per-parameter popup (#param-popup or similar) built on demand for the clicked param:

  • min slider (range 0–1)
  • max slider (range 0–1)
  • curve slider (range 0–1, see Theme 4)
  • freeze toggle — when frozen, dragging the heatmap bar updates a fixed value directly rather than going through the model
  • close button / clicks-outside dismissal
  • show/hide handled with popupHideTimer (300ms grace period to let user move pointer from heatmap cell into the popup without dismiss-on-leave)

New JS

  • setHeatmapValue(paramIndex, e, cell) — converts pointer x to normalized value, applies override semantics (writes to ov.fixedValue if frozen), routes outputs, syncs UI.
  • showParamPopup(paramIndex, cell) — positions popup near the cell.
  • hideParamPopup() — clears active popup state.
  • wireParamPopup() — wires popup controls to update underlying override.
  • Tracking globals: activePopupParam, popupHideTimer.

Inferred intent

  • Make the heatmap a control surface, not just a readout. Saves a trip to the bottom-sheet/drawer for common adjustments.
  • Per-parameter freeze enables hybrid workflow: freeze a few params at fixed values while letting the model drive the rest.
  • Popup is in-context (anchored to the bar) rather than in a side panel, reducing eye travel.

Key UX flow

  • Quick adjust: point at heatmap bar → drag horizontally → value changes live, model output reroutes immediately.
  • Override setup: click bar → popup opens → adjust min/max to constrain range, or freeze at fixed value, or shape curve (see Theme 4) → click outside or wait for cell pointer-leave to dismiss.

Notes

  • .heatmap-cell-frozen CSS class dims frozen cells visually so user knows what's manually overridden.
  • Drag detection uses 3px motion threshold to disambiguate click-vs-drag.
  • Pointer capture (setPointerCapture) ensures drag continues even if pointer leaves the cell.

Theme 3 — Undo

What changed

Adds an undo button below the RL thumbs-up/down buttons, with a 20-step history of weight snapshots taken before each RL action.

Implementation

  • New HTML: <button class="rl-undo-btn" id="btn-undo"> in the RL buttons cluster, with an SVG curl-arrow icon.
  • New CSS: .rl-undo-btn (28px circle, dim-by-default at opacity 0.4, brightens to 0.8 on hover, 0.7 when undo is available), .rl-undo-btn.has-undo and .rl-undo-btn.flash states. Animation rl-flash (0.25s ease-out) for feedback after undo.
  • Layout: .rl-buttons becomes display: grid with two columns and two rows; the undo button spans both columns in row 2 (grid-column: 1 / -1) and is centered.
  • New JS:
    • const undoStack = [] and const MAX_UNDO = 20
    • pushUndoSnapshot() — called before each RL action; clones current weights into the stack; pops oldest if over MAX_UNDO.
    • onUndo() — pops last snapshot, restores weights, flashes button.
    • updateUndoButton() — toggles .has-undo class based on undoStack.length > 0.

Inferred intent

  • RL actions in this playground are exploratory and easy to "go too far" — e.g. a thumbs-down sequence that drives the model into uninteresting territory. Without undo, user has to retrain or randomize, losing all history.
  • Visual subtlety (low default opacity, only fully visible when there's something to undo) keeps it out of the way until needed.

Key UX flow

User clicks 👎 → push snapshot, apply update. Result is bad. User clicks ↶ → restores previous weights. Button flashes briefly to confirm.

Notes

  • This is the cleanest standalone theme — minimal coupling to the rest of the redesign. Consider implementing first in the SolidJS rewrite to validate the snapshot model.

Theme 4 — Per-parameter override generalization

What changed

Generalizes the existing groupOverrides system (which let synth-mode params be constrained per-group) to also work in visual mode, and unifies access behind a single getParamOverride(i) accessor.

New shapes

  • const visualOverrides = VISUAL_PARAM_NAMES.map(() => ({ min: 0, max: 1, curve: 0.5, frozen: false, fixedValue: 0.5 })) — one override entry per visual parameter, parallel to the existing per-section/per-param structure on the synth side.
  • getParamOverride(paramIndex) — given a heatmap index, returns an object with the same shape regardless of mode:
    • In visual mode: returns the corresponding visualOverrides[i] entry directly.
    • In synth mode: looks up paramToSection[paramIndex] and returns a proxy onto groupOverrides[si].params[li], with muted mapped to frozen so the popup UI can be mode-agnostic.

Renames (cosmetic but indicative)

  • buildRawParams() → buildEngineParams()
  • $rawParams → $engineParams
  • HTML id raw-params → engine-params

New JS helpers

  • syncEngineParams() — pull current values into the drawer-rendered slider list.
  • formatEngineVal(v, step) — display formatting for slider readouts.

Other change

  • let rlExplorationDecay = 0.97 (was const) — runtime-tunable, presumably exposed via an Engine drawer slider.

Inferred intent

  • Visual mode previously had no way to clamp/freeze individual parameters. Synth mode did. The asymmetry forced the heatmap popup to behave differently per mode, which is poor UX.
  • Unifying behind one accessor lets Theme 2's popup code be mode-agnostic.
  • "Engine" terminology generalizes "raw params" to whichever output system is active.

Notes

  • This theme is coupled to Theme 2 — the popup is what consumes the override accessor. They should ship together (or, in the SolidJS rewrite, be designed together as one feature: "per-parameter constraints + the UI to set them").

Theme 5 — Polish (positioning, status line)

Small adjustments forced by the larger redesign or independent quality-of-life fixes:

  • Status line moves from inside the sheet (<div class="sheet-status">) to a free-floating pill anchored at bottom: 8px, centered, low-opacity (#status-line). Lives outside any drawer; visible always.
  • Joystick & hand-pip move from bottom: 136px to bottom: 100px (sheet no longer takes up vertical space).
  • RL buttons move from bottom: 92px to bottom: 36px, gap from 32px to 12px, layout from flex to 2-col grid (to accommodate the spanning undo button below).
  • rlExplorationDecay changes from const to let (see Theme 4).
  • Heatmap tooltip gets ▾ suffix to hint clickability and stays visible during drag.
  • Hand-pip video loses /* Hidden — only used as MediaPipe source */ comment on the position-absolute hidden video element. Behavior unchanged.

Notes

  • These are positioning constants tied to the shape of the surrounding layout. The SolidJS rewrite shouldn't carry them forward as literals — derive from layout / CSS variables.

What this redesign does NOT change

For completeness — these survived the redesign untouched:

  • Joystick container and joystick interaction logic (wireJoystick).
  • Hand tracker / MediaPipe pipeline (createDevPanel(() => handTracker)).
  • Synth visualizer canvas (#synth-vis-canvas, SYNTH_SECTIONS).
  • Loss canvas drawing.
  • Help overlay (wireHelp).
  • Group overrides for synth mode (extended in Theme 4, but base mechanism unchanged).
  • Gamepad input.
  • Output mode routing logic (routeOutputs, rawParamValues).

Summary table for the SolidJS rewrite

Theme Carry forward? How it should land in SolidJS
1. Dock + drawers Yes <Dock> + <DrawerStack> driven by signal for active drawer
2. Interactive heatmap Yes Heatmap cells as components with pointer-event handlers; popup as a portal anchored to clicked cell
3. Undo Yes Single store with undo() action + size cap; trivially reactive
4. Param override generalization Yes One unified store keyed by param index; mode is just a derived accessor
5. Polish Re-derive Don't carry positioning literals; recompute from layout