memlnaut-nisps/.factory/validation/output-modes-heatmap/scrutiny/reviews/f13-output-mode-switching.json
monkey-w1n5t0n a81c9047d1 scrutiny: output-modes-heatmap milestone validation — all 3 features pass review
Validators: 214/214 tests pass, typecheck clean, lint clean.
Reviews: f13 (output mode switching), f14 (heatmap strip), f15 (param popup) all pass.
Non-blocking issues noted (undo stack on resize, window.confirm style, unused applyAllOverrides).
Library updates: added ModeDrawer docs, fixed applyAllOverrides typo, noted disconnected override pipeline.

Co-authored-by: factory-droid[bot] <138933559+factory-droid[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
2026-04-07 21:54:11 +02:00

34 lines
3.4 KiB
JSON

{
"featureId": "f13-output-mode-switching",
"reviewedAt": "2026-04-07T19:30:00.000Z",
"commitId": "08e892d",
"transcriptSkeletonReviewed": true,
"diffReviewed": true,
"status": "pass",
"codeReview": {
"summary": "Well-implemented output mode switching with MLP resize, confirmation dialog, warm-start weight transfer, and pill toggle UI. The code is clean, follows existing patterns (drawer components, SolidJS conventions), and has comprehensive test coverage (18 tests). Found 2 non-blocking issues: (1) mode state updates optimistically before confirmation dialog could theoretically be canceled by other means, and (2) undo stack and loss history are not cleared on destructive resize, which may confuse users who see stale undo/loss state after switching modes.",
"issues": [
{
"file": "src/stores/ml-store.ts",
"line": 325,
"severity": "non_blocking",
"description": "Confirmation dialog uses window.confirm() which is synchronous and blocking. While functional, it's inconsistent with the glass-morphism UI design language. Additionally, if the confirm dialog is somehow bypassed or the mode state is set externally (e.g., via debug probe), the confirmation is skipped. The confirm guard is only in setOutputMode(), not in resizeMLP() itself."
},
{
"file": "src/stores/ml-store.ts",
"line": 328,
"severity": "non_blocking",
"description": "After destructive resize (confirmation accepted, resizeMLP runs), the undo stack and loss history are not cleared. The undo stack still contains snapshots from the previous MLP, and lossHistory is stale. While this doesn't cause crashes (undo restores weights to the new MLP since warm-start uses new MLP), it could confuse users who undo past a mode switch boundary. The existing test suite does not verify undo behavior across mode switches."
}
]
},
"sharedStateObservations": [
{
"area": "knowledge",
"observation": "The ModeDrawer component and pill-toggle CSS pattern are not documented in .factory/library/architecture.md. The Dock section lists Mode as a drawer toggle but there's no ModeDrawer section describing its props, behavior, or pill-toggle pattern. Future workers implementing similar drawer panels won't find this reference.",
"evidence": "architecture.md has sections for Dock, TrainingDrawer, StatusLine, RLButtons, HeatmapStrip, ParamPopup but none for ModeDrawer. The pill-toggle CSS pattern (`.pill-toggle`, `.pill-opt`, `.pill-opt.active`) is only in drawer.css with no architectural documentation."
}
],
"addressesFailureFrom": null,
"summary": "The f13 output mode switching feature is well-implemented and passes review. The core functionality (4 output modes with correct counts: visual=20, synth=126, midi-cc=8, audio-canvas=36) works correctly. MLP warm-start properly preserves hidden layer weights during mode switches (verified by VAL-MODE-007 tests comparing weight arrays before/after). The confirmation dialog correctly triggers only when training examples exist and resize is needed. The pill toggle UI is clean and follows the existing glass morphism design system. 18 Playwright tests provide comprehensive coverage across all 7 VAL-MODE assertions plus UI integration. Two non-blocking issues noted: (1) undo stack not cleared on destructive resize, (2) window.confirm() is functional but stylistically inconsistent with the app's custom UI. No blocking issues found."
}