{ "featureId": "f15-param-popup", "reviewedAt": "2026-04-07T20:30:00.000Z", "commitId": "c147df5", "transcriptSkeletonReviewed": true, "diffReviewed": true, "status": "pass", "codeReview": { "summary": "The f15-param-popup feature implements a well-structured ParamPopup component with curve drag, range sliders, and freeze toggle. The code is clean, follows existing project conventions (plain CSS, SolidJS patterns, glass morphism design system), and includes 19 Playwright tests covering all 4 validation assertions. The param-overrides.ts module provides clean, well-documented utility functions. There is one non-blocking observation: `applyAllOverrides()` is defined but never called in the output pipeline — consumers currently read raw ML outputs without overrides applied. This is acceptable for the current milestone (the popup stores overrides correctly and the store API is complete), but will need wiring before the output pipeline is finalized.", "issues": [ { "file": "src/stores/ml-store.ts", "line": 180, "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "`applyAllOverrides()` is defined on the store interface and implemented but never called anywhere. Consumers like FlowField.tsx, HeatmapStrip.tsx, and the debug probe read `outputs()` which returns raw ML values without override transformation. The overrides are stored correctly, but they don't affect actual output routing yet. This is fine for this milestone since the popup's responsibility is to capture and store overrides — the output pipeline integration is a separate concern." }, { "file": ".factory/library/architecture.md", "line": 128, "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "Documentation typo: says `applyAllOutputs(Float32Array)` but the actual method name is `applyAllOverrides(Float32Array)`. Minor docs inconsistency." } ] }, "sharedStateObservations": [ { "area": "knowledge", "observation": "The `applyAllOverrides()` method on MLStore is a complete dead-code path — defined but never invoked. Future workers implementing output routing or the output pipeline need to know they should call `store.applyAllOverrides(rawOutputs)` to get the transformed outputs. Without this documentation, a worker could easily wire outputs() directly and skip override application.", "evidence": "src/stores/ml-store.ts:584 defines applyAllOverrides. Grep for 'applyAllOverrides' across all .ts/.tsx files shows zero call sites outside its definition. Meanwhile, FlowField.tsx:44, HeatmapStrip.tsx:85/206, and debug-probe.ts:50 all call `store.outputs()` which returns raw values." } ], "addressesFailureFrom": null, "summary": "PASS. The ParamPopup implementation is solid — clean component architecture, correct curve math, proper min/max enforcement, and freeze/unfreeze with value capture. All 19 tests pass and cover the 4 validation assertions comprehensively. The only noteworthy observation is that `applyAllOverrides()` is a complete but disconnected API — overrides are stored correctly but not yet wired into the output routing pipeline. This is acceptable scope for this feature (popup + override storage), but should be tracked for the output pipeline integration milestone." }