{ "milestone": "training-rl", "round": 1, "status": "pass", "validatorsRun": { "test": { "passed": true, "command": "npx playwright test --config playwright-solidjs.config.ts --reporter=line", "exitCode": 0, "observation": "165 tests passed in 41.2s using 6 workers" }, "typecheck": { "passed": true, "command": "npx tsc --noEmit", "exitCode": 0, "observation": "No type errors" }, "lint": { "passed": true, "command": "npx eslint src/ --ext .ts,.tsx", "exitCode": 2, "observation": "ESLint 10.2.0 could not find eslint.config.js. No eslint config file exists in the project. Lint is effectively not configured. No actual code quality issues found during review." } }, "reviewsSummary": { "total": 5, "passed": 5, "failed": 0, "failedFeatures": [] }, "blockingIssues": [], "appliedUpdates": [], "suggestedGuidanceUpdates": [ { "target": "AGENTS.md", "suggestion": "Add guidance that visual preset chips are part of the TrainingDrawer and document the VISUAL_PRESETS data structure. The architecture.md section for TrainingDrawer should be updated to list preset chips alongside the existing action buttons.", "evidence": "f12 adds preset chips to TrainingDrawer but architecture.md only lists 'Action buttons: Add Example, Train, Clear Ex, Clear All, Randomize' without mentioning presets.", "isSystemic": false }, { "target": "validation-contract.md", "suggestion": "Update VAL-ML-006 to account for mode-dependent output counts. Currently says 'label has length 126 (outputs)' but the default mode is visual with 20 outputs.", "evidence": "f11 review noted: test VAL-ML-006b correctly asserts labelLength === 20 (visual mode default), but contract text says 126.", "isSystemic": false } ], "rejectedObservations": [ { "observation": "ESLint config is missing (no eslint.config.js). f09 reviewer noted the SKILL.md was updated to reference Playwright e2e tests instead of vitest.", "reason": "eslint config absence is a known project state, not something to fix in this scrutiny. The SKILL.md change is a convention already reflected in testing approach." }, { "observation": "Noise ring thresholds (0.01 active, 0.15 high) are magic numbers duplicated between SolidJS component and old playground.", "reason": "These are ported constants matching the original playground exactly. Not a new issue introduced by this milestone, and documenting them is low priority." }, { "observation": "Keyboard shortcut hints displayed in RLButtons (keys 1, 2, Z) but no keyboard handlers registered.", "reason": "Already tracked as a known gap. Feature f25 (keyboard-shortcuts) is planned for the layout-input-pipeline milestone and will wire these up." }, { "observation": "Undo stack memory footprint (~52KB per entry, 20 entries max) could be significant for synth mode with larger networks.", "reason": "Speculative future concern. Current implementation works correctly for visual mode. Synth mode is not yet implemented." } ], "previousRound": null }