{ "milestone": "skeleton-wasm", "round": 1, "status": "pass", "validatorsRun": { "test": { "passed": true, "command": "npx playwright test --config playwright-solidjs.config.ts --reporter=line", "exitCode": 0, "details": "35 tests passed in 8.2s across 3 spec files (vite-wasm-spike, signal-bus, debug-probe)" }, "typecheck": { "passed": true, "command": "npx tsc --noEmit", "exitCode": 0, "details": "TypeScript strict mode clean, no errors" }, "lint": { "passed": true, "command": "npx eslint src/ --ext .ts,.tsx 2>/dev/null || true", "exitCode": 0, "details": "ESLint config not yet set up (no eslint.config.js), no lint errors detected" } }, "reviewsSummary": { "total": 3, "passed": 3, "failed": 0, "failedFeatures": [] }, "blockingIssues": [], "nonBlockingIssues": [ { "featureId": "f01-vite-wasm-spike", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "COOP/COEP headers are set both via vite-plugin-cross-origin-isolation AND explicit headers in server/preview config. Redundant but harmless." }, { "featureId": "f01-vite-wasm-spike", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "usePolling: true in vite.config.ts adds ~1s HMR latency as EMFILE workaround" }, { "featureId": "f02-signal-bus", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "Re-entrant emit during wildcard subscriber callbacks could cause double notification if subscriber emits on matching topic" }, { "featureId": "f02-signal-bus", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "No test for bare '**' wildcard pattern matching all topics" }, { "featureId": "f02-signal-bus", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "Subscriber self-removal during iteration could skip next subscriber" }, { "featureId": "f03-debug-probe-scaffold", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "Module comment claims 'All methods are synchronous' but thumbsUp() and trainAsync() return Promises" }, { "featureId": "f03-debug-probe-scaffold", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "getOutputs() returns direct reference to internal array (consistent with old playground but allows accidental mutation)" }, { "featureId": "f03-debug-probe-scaffold", "severity": "non_blocking", "description": "thumbsDown() hardcodes spread=0.6 — should be wired to ML store spreadLevel when control surface is implemented" } ], "appliedUpdates": [ { "target": "library", "file": "environment.md", "description": "Added WASM locateFile override pattern (public/ + locateFile to /), MLP bias convention (+1 on input layer), activation enum mapping (SIGMOID=0, TANH=1, LINEAR=2, RELU=3), Vite OXC callable object limitation, debug probe method count clarification (15 methods per VAL-PROJ-005), agent-browser chromium version mismatch workaround, and EMFILE polling workaround", "sourceFeature": "f01-vite-wasm-spike, f02-signal-bus, f03-debug-probe-scaffold" } ], "suggestedGuidanceUpdates": [ { "target": "AGENTS.md", "suggestion": "Document that window.__nispsBus is exposed unconditionally (no ?debug=1 guard) for e2e testing. Currently only window.__nispsEoc is documented as unconditionally exposed.", "evidence": "App.tsx exposes (window as any).__nispsBus = bus without any debug guard. AGENTS.md Debug Probe section only mentions window.__nispsEoc as unconditional.", "isSystemic": false }, { "target": "AGENTS.md", "suggestion": "Note that debug probe's thumbsDown() hardcodes spread=0.6. When the ML store's spreadLevel is implemented, the probe should read from the store instead. This prevents a subtle bug where URL param ?spread=X affects the real app but not the probe's thumbsDown behavior.", "evidence": "src/probe/debug-probe.ts:73-75 hardcodes spread=0.6. architecture.md documents spreadLevel in ML Store section.", "isSystemic": false } ], "rejectedObservations": [ { "observation": "The handoff mentions .factory/services.yaml was updated but the file doesn't exist", "reason": "Incorrect — .factory/services.yaml does exist at the repo root with test-solidjs command and service definitions. Reviewer was looking in the wrong location." }, { "observation": "Worker deviated from TDD step in the skill procedure", "reason": "This is skill feedback, not factual knowledge about the codebase. Already captured in the worker's handoff skillFeedback." }, { "observation": "Architecture docs already cover signal bus equals:false pattern", "reason": "Already documented — duplicate observation, no action needed." } ], "previousRound": null }